SMART Goals for Students with ADHD: Do They Actually Work?

A woman wearing glasses gestures with both hands beside the headline "Are SMART Goals Really Smart?" against a yellow and light blue background.

It was Sunday morning, and I popped into the Anti-Boring Learning Lab for a quick check-in. A question from one of our members caught my attention:

SMART goals are used to create and assess progress in Occupational Therapy. But I have heard EF Coaches recommend this as well. Some start out with developing them in the very first session. Does anyone use them on a regular basis in coaching? What are your thoughts?

I couldn't resist responding:

I can never remember what the acronym for SMART means — and I have found it too many steps to remember with students. But I don’t know what the research says! My hunch is that Planning is already a complex EF task, and a student having to walk through five whole steps just to set a goal is too many. But I’ll look into it!

And then I thought, why not research it RIGHT NOW?! So instead of closing my laptop and enjoying my Sunday morning, I went straight down the research rabbit hole.

A note about this research: This was a targeted review of published studies and research reviews, not a comprehensive systematic review. When I say I didn’t find evidence, that isn’t proof that no relevant study exists.

And what I found surprised me!

First, What ARE SMART Goals?

For anyone else who has trouble remembering what the acronym stands for (please tell me I'm not alone!), here's the version most commonly used today:

  • S — Specific: Clearly define what you want to accomplish.

  • M — Measurable: Identify how you'll know you're making progress or have succeeded.

  • A — Achievable: Make sure the goal is something you can realistically accomplish.

  • R — Relevant: Connect the goal to something that matters.

  • T — Time-bound: Establish a deadline or timeframe.

For example, perhaps I need a SMART goal to keep myself from working on Sunday mornings:

"I will not open my laptop before 9 a.m. on weekdays or at all on weekends unless I've scheduled an official work session."

Specific? Check.

Measurable? Check.

Achievable? Last Sunday, no, but I hadn’t set the goal yet!

Note: that last part—whether a goal should be achievable—turns out to be more interesting than I expected. But we'll get to that!

Five Things I Learned About SMART Goals

We’re going to dig into some of the fascinating details momentarily. But I thought I’d start with the quick overview. Here are five main ideas that jumped out from my short literature review:

1. SMART goals weren't originally developed from scientific research, but more recent experiments suggest they can help. The framework originated in business management in 1981, not in research on how people learn or achieve goals. Since then, some experiments have found benefits from using SMART goals. But the evidence doesn't establish that SMART is better than other goal-setting approaches, particularly for students with executive function challenges.

2. A goal can be both achievable and challenging. Goal-setting research suggests that specific, difficult goals can improve performance under the right conditions. ‘Achievable’ shouldn’t automatically mean ‘something the student can already do easily.’

3. Sometimes the best goal is to learn HOW to do something, rather than simply accomplish it. Researchers distinguish between performance goals and learning goals. When students don’t yet know how to succeed at something, a learning goal may be more useful than a performance target. SMART can be used for either kind of goal, but the acronym itself does not prompt us to ask which kind we need.

4. A well-written goal isn't the same as having the tools to achieve it. This is particularly important for students with executive function challenges. They may know exactly what they want to accomplish but still need help figuring out how to initiate, organize, monitor, and follow through. Just naming and tracking a SMART goal is different than getting support with the EF skills you need to achieve it.

5. Maybe SMART is a tool for the coach, not necessarily a lesson for the student? Coaches might find the framework useful for guiding a goal-setting conversation without requiring students to learn or remember the five-part formula themselves. So just because SMART’s added value compared with other goal-setting approaches is not well established doesn’t mean it isn’t a useful framework for guiding a coaching conversation.

Okay! That's the short version of my takeaways. But now let's dig into the research.

1. SMART Goals Have Some Research Behind Them. But How Much?

First, a little history.

SMART goals originated in a 1981 business management article by George Doran. They weren't developed from scientific research on goal-setting; they were a practical tool for helping managers write clearer objectives. And here's something I didn't know: the original A stood for "Assignable," not "Achievable," and the R stood for "Realistic," not "Relevant." As SMART spread beyond business management, the acronym evolved, although it's unclear exactly when or why those changes happened. Doran also didn't insist that every objective satisfy all five criteria (Doran, 1981).

And here’s a twist: even Doran warned against focusing only on the objective. He wrote, ‘It is the combination of the objective and its action plan that is really important.’

It's easy to see why SMART caught on. It gives people a shared language for turning vague intentions into clearer goals, documenting what they're working toward, and evaluating progress.

But how well does the research support it?

A narrative review focused on physical activity promotion, first published online in 2022, raised some pointed criticisms of SMART. Those findings don’t directly tell us what works in academic coaching, but they challenge the assumption that SMART is a universally validated formula (Swann et al., 2022).

That doesn't mean SMART is useless. But it does mean we should be cautious about treating it as a scientifically established formula. But there IS experimental evidence that SMART can help!

In one study, researchers asked university students to choose personally meaningful goals they wanted to accomplish over the next week.

Some students received instructions for using SMART to analyze and refine their goals. Others simply selected their goals without receiving that additional guidance.

After one week, students rated how completely they had achieved their chosen goal. Average self-rated completion was about 73% in the SMART group, compared with 64% in the comparison group (Bahrami et al., 2022). The study involved university students generally, not students selected for ADHD or executive function difficulties.

That’s a positive finding—but there’s an important catch. The SMART group received structured guidance that the comparison group didn't. The study supports the SMART instructional package, but it doesn’t tell us whether SMART works better than an equally thorough alternative approach to planning.

Another study involving medical residents found that incorporating SMART goal-writing into training debriefings increased the number of educational actions participants reported taking afterward (Aghera et al., 2018).

Again, encouraging! But medical residents aren't middle school students struggling to remember to turn in their homework.

The researchers stopped recruitment early after finding statistical significance, which warrants additional caution.

Another study took a different approach. Researchers compared SMART goals with simply telling participants to "do your best" or encouraging them to explore possibilities without a specific target. They tested these approaches during a short creative-thinking exercise (Pietsch et al., 2024).

So here's where the research leaves us:

SMART can be helpful, but we don't have convincing evidence that it's consistently better than other structured ways of setting goals.

And nothing in the research I reviewed establishes that every student with executive function challenges needs to learn the acronym.

2. Achievable Doesn’t Have to Mean Easy

One of the most influential bodies of research on goal-setting comes from psychologists Edwin Locke and Gary Latham.

Across decades of research, they found that specific, challenging goals often produce better performance than vague goals like "do your best" or goals that are too easy (Locke & Latham, 2006).

That doesn’t create a conflict with the A in SMART. It does raise a question: what do we mean by “achievable?”

Because when we tell students their goals need to be "achievable" or "realistic," what exactly do we mean?

Do we mean something they can reasonably accomplish with effort, strategies, and support?

Or do we mean something they're already pretty sure they can do?

Those aren't the same thing!

Imagine a student who currently turns in about half of their assignments.

  • Would we encourage them to set a goal of turning in 60%? Because that seems achievable?

  • What if the student wants to aim for 90%? Should we discourage that because it might be too ambitious?

Not necessarily. A student might care about eventually reaching 90% while choosing a much smaller experiment for this week. We don’t have to choose between an ambitious direction and a manageable next step.

The research suggests that challenging goals can motivate people to direct more attention and effort toward a task, persist longer, and develop better strategies.

But there are important conditions. People need to be committed to the goal, have appropriate resources and feedback, and possess—or be able to develop—the skills needed to succeed.

And here's an important distinction: challenging doesn't mean impossible.

An ambitious goal can be motivating. A goal that feels completely out of reach may not be.

For students with ADHD or other executive function challenges, we also need to distinguish between the difficulty of the goal and the support needed to pursue it. A student might be capable of accomplishing something ambitious while still needing substantial scaffolding to get there.

This research doesn't tell us to abandon the A in SMART. But it does suggest we should be careful about what we mean by "achievable."

Maybe the question isn’t simply, “Can you do this?” Maybe it’s, “What would it take for you to do this?”

3. Sometimes the Best Goal Is to Learn HOW to Do Something

Researchers often distinguish between performance goals and learning goals.

  • A performance goal focuses on achieving a particular result. For example: "I will get at least 85% on my next biology test."

  • A learning goal focuses on developing the knowledge or strategies needed to succeed. For example: "I will figure out which study strategies help me remember and explain the biology concepts without looking at my notes."

Both are legitimate goals. But they serve different purposes.

When someone already knows how to perform a task, a specific, challenging performance goal can be useful.

When someone is learning something complex or unfamiliar, however, focusing too heavily on the desired performance can actually interfere with figuring out how to do the task.

In an experiment involving a complex business simulation, researchers found that participants assigned a specific learning goal performed better than participants assigned a specific performance goal or a vague goal (Seijts et al., 2004).

Why might that matter for academic coaching?

Because students often come to us precisely because they DON'T YET KNOW HOW to accomplish what they're trying to accomplish!

They want better grades, fewer missing assignments, less procrastination, or more independence.

Some students haven’t yet found an effective strategy. Others can explain exactly what they’re supposed to do but struggle to use that strategy consistently. Those are different coaching problems—and neither is solved merely by writing a clearer performance target.

Imagine a student who says, "I want to stop procrastinating."

We could help them turn that into a SMART performance goal: "I will start my homework within 15 minutes of getting home from school at least four days a week." That's clear and measurable.

But what if the student has absolutely no idea how to get themselves started?

Maybe a learning goal would be more useful: "This week, I want to experiment with different ways to get started on homework and figure out which ones actually work for me."

The student could try working alongside someone, breaking the first assignment into a tiny starting step, or changing where they work.

Then the coach and student can examine what happened.

Notice that the learning goal could ALSO be written in SMART format. SMART and learning goals aren't competing systems.

The important distinction is what we're asking the student to accomplish. Are they trying to hit a performance target? Or are they trying to develop the strategies that will eventually make that performance possible?

For academic coaches, that seems like an especially useful question.

Good coaching starts with good questions.

Want more practical strategies and fresh perspectives on executive function coaching?

Explore the Free Library →

4. A Well-Written Goal Isn't the Same as Having the Tools to Achieve It

Now we're getting closer to my response when the Lab member asked the original question.

Here’s a twist: even the person who introduced SMART warned against focusing only on the objective. Back in 1981, Doran wrote, “It is the combination of the objective and its action plan that is really important.”

Planning is complicated!

  • Setting a goal involves imagining a future outcome, identifying priorities, evaluating possibilities, and making decisions.

  • Following through may involve task initiation, working memory, organization, attention regulation, monitoring, and adjusting when things don't go as expected.

For students who struggle with executive function, those demands can be substantial.

So does adding five SMART criteria help organize the process? Or does it make an already complicated task more complicated?

Here’s what I discovered: I didn’t find good direct evidence answering that question.

I didn’t find controlled research directly testing whether teaching the SMART formula improves executive functioning in students with ADHD. I also didn’t find evidence directly showing that SMART itself creates excessive cognitive load for these students.

So my original hunch remains a hunch.

What we DO have is research on interventions that help students develop and use organizational and self-management skills.

For example, a systematic review and meta-analysis of 12 randomized studies involving more than 1,000 children with ADHD found that organizational-skills interventions improved organizational functioning, with smaller benefits for academic outcomes (Bikic et al., 2017).

Another small study involving college students with ADHD compared study-skills instruction and goal-setting with the same approach plus self-monitoring. The researchers found promising improvements in the group receiving self-monitoring support (Scheithauer & Kelley, 2014).

Neither study tested SMART specifically.

But both help illuminate something important: students often need more than a clearly stated goal.

They need ways to act on that goal.

They may need to learn strategies, arrange environmental supports, practice new behaviors, monitor what's happening, and adjust their approach.

That is why a coach may need to distinguish between a student who needs a new strategy and one who needs help using a strategy they already know.

And this is where the Anti-Boring Learning Lab's distinction between (1) knowing a strategy and (2) actually knowing how to teach it becomes relevant.

It's one thing for a coach to know that a student needs a specific, measurable goal.

It's another thing to help that student figure out how to make progress toward it.

That requires both knowledge of executive function and the craft of coaching: knowing when to ask questions, when to model a strategy, when to provide structure, and when to gradually hand responsibility back to the student.

A beautifully written goal doesn't do all that work for us.

5. Could SMART Be a Tool for the Coach, Not Necessarily a Lesson for the Student?

This last idea brings me back to the Learning Lab member's original question.

Occupational therapists often use structured goals to identify what they and their clients are working toward and to assess progress.

That's a legitimate professional purpose.

And I can see how an executive function coach might find SMART useful in a similar way.

But here's the distinction I'm interested in:

Does the student actually need to learn the SMART formula? Or does the coach need to understand what makes a goal useful?

And what about setting SMART goals in the very first session? I didn’t find research directly comparing that timing with developing formal goals later in EF coaching. My own takeaway isn’t that early goals are wrong. It’s that I wouldn’t make a polished SMART statement the price of admission to coaching.

Imagine a student says, "I want to be more organized."

A coach who's thinking about SMART might ask:

  • "What does being more organized look like to you?"

  • "Where is disorganization causing the biggest problems?"

  • "What would you like to be different?"

  • "How would you know things were improving?"

  • "When should we check in and see how it's going?"

That's a perfectly natural coaching conversation.

The coach might be using SMART principles to guide their questions without ever saying, "Okay, now let's make sure your goal is Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound."

The student gets help clarifying a goal without having to learn a five-part acronym.

And perhaps that's enough.

Of course, some students might genuinely benefit from learning SMART themselves. A structured framework can externalize thinking and make an abstract task more manageable. For some students—including some neurodivergent learners—explicit structure may be particularly useful.

For others, the extra terminology and criteria might be unnecessary.

I didn’t find research directly comparing coach-guided use of SMART with explicitly teaching students the formula. And we shouldn't assume that students with ADHD all need the same amount or type of structure.

But I think there's a broader instructional question here that's worth asking:

What does the coach need to know in order to facilitate effective goal-setting, and what does the student actually need to learn?

Those aren't necessarily identical.

In the Anti-Boring Learning Lab, we spend a lot of time helping educators develop expertise in the science of learning, executive function, and emotional regulation—not because students need to become experts in all those fields, but because that knowledge helps educators make better instructional decisions.

Goal-setting might be another example.

Perhaps the most important thing isn't whether the student can produce a perfectly formatted SMART goal.

Perhaps it's whether the coach and student can identify something meaningful to work toward, figure out what it will take, and recognize progress along the way.

So, Are SMART Goals Actually Smart?

Well, I started this research rabbit hole feeling pretty skeptical about SMART goals. Five steps just to set a goal?! For a student who's already struggling with executive function?!

And after reading the research, I'm still not convinced that students need to learn the SMART formula.

But I am more convinced that thoughtful goal-setting instruction matters. And I learned some things I hadn't expected—especially about the value of challenging goals and the difference between setting a goal to achieve something and setting a goal to learn HOW to achieve it.

Setting a good goal and knowing how to pursue it are related, but different, skills.

Which brings me back to what we work on in the Anti-Boring Learning Lab: knowing the science is good, but it's not enough. We also need to know how to help students put that knowledge into action.

So, did my Sunday-morning research prove that SMART goals ask too much of students with executive function challenges?

Nope. My hunch is still a hunch.

It did remind me to separate two questions: What makes a goal useful? And what does a student need in order to work toward it?

Those questions overlap, but they aren’t identical.

I’m not leaving this rabbit hole with a plan to make every student learn SMART. I’m also not leaving with a reason to tell coaches to stop using it.

What I am leaving with is a question I want us to keep asking: Is this framework helping this student think and act—or are we making the student do extra work to satisfy the framework?

Sometimes I may use SMART quietly to guide my questions. Sometimes I may teach it explicitly. And sometimes the most useful goal may be, “Let’s figure out what helps you get started.”

The goal of coaching isn’t a perfectly formatted sentence. It’s helping a student move toward something that matters, with support they can actually use.

As for my weekend laptop habits? Apparently I have an opportunity to experiment.

SMART Goals and Executive Function Coaching: Quick Answers

Looking for a quick answer? Here are the main takeaways.

Are SMART goals evidence-based?

There is some experimental evidence that SMART goal-setting can improve short-term goal progress, but research hasn't established that SMART is consistently better than other goal-setting approaches. At the Anti-Boring Learning Lab, we're interested in understanding which parts of an approach actually help students—not just whether the approach has a memorable acronym. The strongest direct study I found involved university students generally, not students selected for executive-function difficulties.

Should executive function coaches use SMART goals?

They certainly can! But the research doesn't establish SMART as a required or uniquely effective method for executive function coaching. My approach is to match the tool to the student and help them develop ways to act on their goals.

Are SMART goals good for students with ADHD?

They may be useful, particularly when clear structure helps a student organize their thinking. But we don't have strong direct evidence that SMART is the best goal-setting method for students with ADHD.

What's the difference between a learning goal and a performance goal?

A performance goal describes a result you want to achieve. A learning goal focuses on developing the skills or strategies needed to succeed. In my approach, teaching students how to learn is central, so learning goals can be especially useful when a student hasn't yet figured out an effective approach.

Do students need to learn the SMART acronym?

Not necessarily. A coach might use SMART to guide a conversation without formally teaching the framework. I distinguish between the expertise educators need and the tools students actually need to use. Sometimes teaching a framework is helpful. Sometimes a good coaching conversation does the job.

Works Cited

Aghera, A., et al. (2018). A randomized trial of SMART goal enhanced debriefing after simulation to promote educational actions. Western Journal of Emergency Medicine, 19(1), 112–120. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5785177/

Bahrami, Z., Heidari, A., & Cranney, J. (2022). Applying SMART goal intervention leads to greater goal attainment, need satisfaction and positive affect. International Journal of Mental Health Promotion, 24(6), 869–882. https://www.techscience.com/IJMHP/v24n6/49942/html

Bikic, A., Reichow, B., McCauley, S. A., Ibrahim, K., & Sukhodolsky, D. G. (2017). Meta-analysis of organizational skills interventions for children and adolescents with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. Clinical Psychology Review, 52, 108–123. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28088557/

Doran, G. T. (1981). There's a S.M.A.R.T. way to write management's goals and objectives. Management Review, 70(11), 35–36. https://www.decisionskills.com/uploads/5/1/6/0/5160560/doran_1981_s.m.a.r.t-way-management-review.pdf

Locke, E. A., & Latham, G. P. (2006). New directions in goal-setting theory. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 15(5), 265–268. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8721.2006.00449.x

Pietsch, S., Riddell, H., Semmler, C., Ntoumanis, N., & Gucciardi, D. F. (2024). SMART goals are no more effective for creative performance than do-your-best goals or non-specific, exploratory ‘open goals.’ Educational Psychology, 44(9–10), 946–962. https://doi.org/10.1080/01443410.2024.2420818

Scheithauer, M. C., & Kelley, M. L. (2017). Self-monitoring by college students with ADHD: The impact on academic performance. Journal of Attention Disorders, 21(12), 1030–1039. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25319163/

Seijts, G. H., Latham, G. P., Tasa, K., & Latham, B. W. (2004). Goal setting and goal orientation: An integration of two different yet related literatures. Academy of Management Journal, 47(2), 227–239.

Swann, C., et al. (2023). The (over)use of SMART goals for physical activity promotion: A narrative review and critique. Health Psychology Review, 17(2), 211–226. First published online 2022. https://doi.org/10.1080/17437199.2021.2023608

Next
Next

What Are Educators Missing About Flashcards?